- Owner of Hartnoll Hotel claims she has been loaned trophy
- But Claire Carter refuses to reveal who gave it to her because they don’t want ‘the aggro’
- Experts claim Ms Carter ‘just wants publicity’ and says stag head is not the majestic red deer
- Magnificent red deer disappeared after ‘being shot’ during annual rut last year
Last updated at 6:38 PM on 12th December 2011
It was a shooting that shocked the world and has remained a mystery ever since – who killed the Emperor of Exmoor and where is the magnificent stag’s body?
It is a riddle which may have, in part, been solved by the apparent discovery of the beast’s head in a boutique hotel.
But experts locked horns today over claims that one of Britain’s finest stags has been stuffed and hung on wall at The Hartnoll Hotel in Bolham, near Tiverton, Devon.
Magnificent: It is believed the Emperor of Exmoor was shot by poachers because his head and antlers could be worth as much as £2,000
Is this the Emperor stag? The Hartnoll Hotel in Bolham, near Tiverton, Devon (left) and the stag pictured last year
The magnificent Emperor stag, which stood at nearly 9ft tall, was reportedly shot dead in the middle of the annual rut on Exmoor, Devon, last year.
His carcass was never found and experts feared the antlers had been sold to a private collector for thousands of pounds.
Although the owner of a boutique hotel, just nine miles from where the stag was shot, claims to have the animal’s head mounted on her wall.
Valuable: The Emperor’s antlers, which had a total of 17 points, could fetch a large sum to the right buyer. His meat could also have been sold for up to £300
Locked horns: Hotel owner Claire Carter claims she has been loaned the stags head but experts claim she is ‘after the publicity’ and the stags head differs wildly from Emperor’s
Claire Carter says she was loaned the head by a friend to display in the sitting room of The Hartnoll Hotel in Bolham, near Tiverton, Devon.
She said: ‘He could well be the Emperor, yes. That’s all I can really say, but I do believe it is (the Emperor).’
The stag’s head, with antlers that had a total of 17 points, could be worth £2,000 as a trophy to the right buyer and the meat could be sold for up to £300.
But today a wildlife expert who spent years pursuing the 300lb beast said he was ‘positive’ the head is not that of the Emperor.
Wildlife tracker Dave Webb has been running deer safaris on Exmoor for six years and has seen the Emperor many times over the years.
Impressive: Staff at the hotel in Devon were astonished their stag’s head could be Emperor’s
Demise: The Emperor disappeared during last year’s rut on Exmoor, leading to furious debate, anger and theories that he had been executed
Mr Webb, of North Molton, Devon, said the formation and angle of the antlers are different.
He said: ‘If you compare the antlers there are a few differences which make me believe it’s not The Emperor.
‘The points nearest the eyebrows on the picture taken in the wild of The Emperor are twisted. On the one that’s hanging on the wall in the hotel they are straight.
‘There are also a number of differences in the alignment of the antlers on the two and I really don’t think The Emperor is hanging on the wall in a hotel in north Devon.
Whether the owner genuinely believes it or not I don’t know, but it’s a good bit of advertising.
The Emperor was reported to have been shot near the village of Rackenford, on the southern edge of Exmoor, in October last year.
Outrage: It is believed this grainy picture taken by an Exmoor deer hunter shows a poacher allegedly cutting the Emperor’s throat before phoning an accomplice
Deer lovers were quick to condemn the killing and a debate raged as to whether it had been shot illegally or by a licensed deer stalker.
Its carcass was never found and there were even rumours that its demise was a ‘myth”, invented to protect the animal from rogue hunters.
Weeks later, following huge media interest which made headlines around the world, alleged pictures of its shooting emerged.
Hartnoll Hotel owner Mrs Carter said she believes the head she has in her hotel was that of the magnificent animal – but refused to reveal who she had borrowed it from.
Mystery: Other experts claim the massive stag dubbed ‘Emperor’ is very much still alive, photographer Brad Wakefield said this picture (taken in October last year) proves the stag is alive
She said: ‘The thing is I haven’t actually bought it. I’ve got it on loan. It doesn’t actually belong to me.” Asked about the stag’s origins or why the owner did not want to be identified, she said she had ‘promised faithfully I wouldn’t say anything about that”.
Discussing her agreement with the trophy’s owner, Mrs Carter added: ‘I said ‘well I’ll put it up there and just see how things go and see if it looks nice in the sitting room’ and everybody seems to like it. It does actually enhance the room.’
Staff at the hotel seemed a little bemused after being told the stag’s head could be the Emperor’s.
One said: ‘It’s been on display here four weeks before anything happened.
‘So I imagine somebody saw it and thought it must be the Emperor.
‘I don’t think most staff were aware.
‘We were aware of the original story of the Emperor – we get a lot of shooting parties coming in and staying at the hotel.
Share this article:
Here’s what other readers have said. Why not add your thoughts,
or debate this issue live on our message boards.
The comments below have not been moderated.
Here i was thinking the royal family actually killed the last of the Viking emperors!!
I agree with previous comments, the antlers are different, no way this is the Emperor
Really strange the way animal hunters disguise their warped behaviour by labelling people who don’t hunt animals as ‘townies’. Something really weird about displaying animal heads on your wall – really weird.
Why anyone wants a dead animal on their wall is beyond me!
Comparing the antlers it doesn’t look like him. Regardless it is still a stunning stag, one which I would have enjoyed seeing in the wild. Such a shame people feel the need to do this to such a beautiful animal and one which we all too often forget, once felt emotions, enjoyed living and didn’t want to die.
Seeing an animal like him alive by far beats seeing his head on a wall.
I must visit this hotel. Sounds great thatthey appreciate true country values. I love venison!!!
It is amazing how vitriolic so called animal lovers are and how out of touch they are with nature and sustainable wild life. I could bet anyone of them, unless they are vegan, that they will happy tuck in to pizzas, burgers, turkey and chicken nuggets without giving the animal that died to feed them a seconds thought. They only care if the animal is from the Bamby, thumper or Mr Fox genre. In other words they are selective over the animal they deem fluffy. Bet they don’t give a seconds thought to the millions of rats and mice killed slowly and in great pain each day because they infest their gardens.
It’s not the same stag, the antlers are different.
Commenters here have no proof of the stag’s origin and no proof that a crime has been committed, yet most are willing to destroy this woman’s lively hood. Such hostility reveals who the true barbarians are.
This is the countryside you know. Hunting happens. I am sure the hotel have no objection to the free publicity.
The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.